1

I'm passing around a Binding<T>, where T is numeric value types that NSNumber can handle/support. I need to know if its wrappedValue is signed numeric.

This doesn't work:

extension Binding {
    var isSignedNumeric: Bool {
           wrappedValue is SignedNumeric.  // error: SignedNumeric has `Self` or PAT
    }
}

I'm dong this now:

extension Binding {
    var isSignedNumeric: Bool {
           wrappedValue is Double
        || wrappedValue is Float
        || wrappedValue is Int32
        || wrappedValue is Int
        || wrappedValue is Int64
        || wrappedValue is Int16
    }
}

Is there better way?

1 Like
2

What exactly do you plan on doing with the value, once you know whether or not it is signed?

This comment explains how you can test for conformance to a PAT, and has links for how to actually do things with that conformance.

But if you are working with a fixed set of known types, you might want to just make your own protocol and conform them to it.

3

For conditionally showing the right UI. I'm working with this kind of SwiftUI.TextField:

TextField.init<S, T>(_ title: S, value: Binding, formatter: Formatter)

with .keyboardType(.numberPad) attached to the TextField for entering numbers only. The .numberPad keyboard only has numbers 0-9 and delete and nothing else. I'm adding a keyboard toolbar to allow entering negative value only when the type is signed.

I have access to the binding of the TextField.

T can only be the types NSNumber can handle excluding Bool and Char, these:

Double
Float
Int32
Int
Int64
Int16
UInt8
UInt32
UInt
UInt64
UInt16

I don't know how to constrain T to only these, so I do this T: Numeric but Numeric is not exactly the type above. Or T totally unconstrained, like the TextField.init above.

4

You make a new protocol with the semantics you want (eg. NSNumberConvertible) and conform the types you want to it.

1 Like
5

Thank you! This solve my problem:

protocol NSNumberConvertible { }
protocol SignedNSNumberConvertible: NSNumberConvertible { }
protocol UnsignedNSNumberConvertible: NSNumberConvertible { }

// can do this now
...  wrappedValue is SignedNSNumberConvertible ...

this also solve my other problem :raised_hands:

For learning, I took your code and changed a little to make it work for test if is SignNumeric:

protocol SignedNumericConformanceMarker {}
enum SignedNumericMarker<T> {}
extension SignedNumericMarker: SignedNumericConformanceMarker where T: SignedNumeric {}

func isSignedNumericType<T>(_ t: T.Type) -> Bool {
    return SignedNumericMarker<T>.self is SignedNumericConformanceMarker.Type
}

func isSignedNumeric<T>(_ t: T) -> Bool {
    return isSignedNumericType(T.self)
}

let u: UInt = 0
let i = 0

print("isSignedNumeric(u)", isSignedNumeric(u))     // print: isSignedNumeric(u) false
print("isSignedNumeric(i)", isSignedNumeric(i))     // print: isSignedNumeric(i) true

// make it a little fluent
extension Numeric {
    var isSigned: Bool {
        isSignedNumeric(self)
    }
}

print("u.isSigned", u.isSigned)
print("i.isSigned", i.isSigned)

very interesting how you build thing up and then go from T to T.Type. I can never be able to come up with code like this.

:pray::bowing_woman:t2: