I am locking this thread, as it seems to have become a fuller re-litigation/appeal discussion.
To be clear, this is a fine conversation to have, but it doesn't belong on the acceptance announcement thread. Many people follow the announcements thread to get updates on evolution proposals, but don't want to follow a full evolution discussion, especially not on an already-accepted proposal. We should try and keep the subsequent posts on them focused.
I'm going to create a new thread for this over on the discussion topic.